A Want Is Not a Need
A want is not a need. That’s right. Wants and needs are inherently different. And to need something was once strictly defined as a life “essential” – something vital to “survival, health, etc.” Sadly, over the decades it also came to be virtually synonymous with “desire.” But a want is simply not the same thing as a need. And because so many folks confuse the two, including mental health professionals, I feel obliged to elaborate.
Why is this matter so important? Because it’s crucial to understanding the dynamics associated with narcissism and how to deal with narcissism, whether within a relationship or in therapy. Curiously, even the official criteria for diagnosing narcissism includes the phrase: “a strong need for admiration.” But this is inherently inaccurate. We know that narcissism comes in two main varieties. The “vulnerable” or compensatory (relatively “neurotic”) type can harbor deep insecurities and a fragile sense of self, making them hypersensitive to criticism, and overly dependent on external validation. Accordingly, they crave admiration, adulation, affirmation, etc. (the “A” words associated with narcissism). But that’s not what they truly need. What they need is a healthy, mature, principle-based sense of self. So, ironically, trying to build them up is a tragic mistake that both partners and therapists frequently make.
Grandiose narcissists, harboring attitudes of superiority and entitlement, and who act in haughty, arrogant, demanding, dominance-seeking, and abusive ways are different. You could say they “need” to be the center of attention or to be adored. But just because they crave these things doesn’t mean they truly need them. What they really need is an honest self-reckoning about themselves and their worth. They also need boundaries and limits that are reliably and firmly imposed.
Relationship and Therapy Pitfalls
Too many folks seeking help after involvement with a narcissist experience “iatrogenic” or therapy-induced trama. And that’s largely because narcissism is so poorly understood and dealt with. A charming narcissist, skilled in the art of positive impression management, can pull the wool over the eyes of even some of the best trained therapists. This leaves the person who was at their wits end and finally manage to secure a therapy session feeling worse than before. Sadly, too many times, the same unhealthy dynamics that characterized the relationship get played out in therapy, too, reinforcing a very destructive pattern. And this tends to be true regardless of the type of narcissist dragged into therapy.
(Research has confirmed the major types and subtypes of narcissists I first wrote about in Character Disturbance many years ago. And you can find a more comprehensive explanation there.)
Addressing the Real Needs
What vulnerable/compensatory narcissists need is for partners (and therapists) to do less stroking, walking on eggshells, and, etc., because such things only reinforce an unhealthy pattern. Like their grandiose counterparts, they need benign confrontation and more encouragement to examine the roots of their misguided cravings. And grandiose narcissists need much less attention, virtually no adulation, and certainly no adoration. They might become outraged and even more insistent when denied. But we hurt them, ourselves, and everyone else when we heed their demands. Sometimes the things we want the most are the very last things we actually need!
Sadly, our culture is presently not only witnessing the indulging of some of the worst manifestations of narcissism but actually encouraging it. And again, it’s because we’ve confused wants and needs. What we seem to WANT is for our particular wills to prevail. What we truly NEED, however, is for level-headedness and integity of character to become more commonplace again. By definition, this need is essential to our survival.
I’ll have more to say about these matters in some upcoming posts. And you can find more information on what narcissistically-inclined characters really need in Essentials for the Journey.
